Sunday, August 30, 2015

I first criticized the "Innateness Hypothesis" in 1967, in a paper I collected in Mind, Language and Reality, vol. 2 of my 1975 Philosophical Papers.  That paper was delivered in a debate with my friend, Noam Chomsky, and we have been debating the issue ever since. The following remarks will be included in a lecture I will give via Skype to a conference in Mumbai in October.
Innate language?
 I think it is worth while to say again, here, why I reject the “innateness hypothesis”. Since the most famous advocate of that hypothesis is Noam Chomsky, I will use his version as my target.
The decisive objection, in my view, is that the “universal grammar” that Chomsky postulates has to provide for all possible meanings. Chomsky likens his hypothetical “language organ” to a switch box, and he tells us that when the switches in a child’s brain are appropriately set, “the child has command of a particular language and knows … that a particular expression has a particular meaning and so forth.”[1]  If all possible terms were definable from a number of basic terms that might have been selected for by evolution (such as the logical positivists’ “observation terms”) , this would be compatible with Darwinian evolution.. But Chomsky certainly rejects logical positivism, and he has suggested no alternative account of what the basic terms of “mentalese” might be. Nor has he ever told  us what mechanism could have endowed the brains of primitive men and women with terms with such ‘particular meanings’ as “quantum potential”  and “macroeconomic”, or with terms by means of which they could be defined, if, indeed, there are more elementary terms in which this could be done.
I am well aware that  both Chomsky and Fodor reject Darwinian evolution. (Since that theory is highly successful, and constitutes the beating heart of population genetics, to mention just one part of biology, I would think that is already reason to dismiss their talk of innate language.) Chomsky apparently thinks that the “language organ” appeared in the brain serendipitously, but that the makes the story even crazier. The story that the hundreds of thousands of terms in human languages, and the millions of terms in possible human languages, all correspond to terms in a master vocabulary of ‘Mentalese’, or to a a set of "switch"-settings, supplied to us by serendipity is precisely analogous to supposing that monkeys typed out Proust’s Remembrance of Things Past. (Of course, to reject that story is not to deny that some aspects of language might be innate; that would not be incompatible with evolution.)



[1] Chomsky, Language and the Problems of Knowledge (Cambridge,MA, MIT Press, 1988), pp. 62–63.

23 comments:

  1. If there are modules in the brain for identifying and tracking objects, and perhaps other modules to attribute intentions to other people (as I've heard recently that the theory that we acquire a theory of mind only at a certain age is still controversial) couldn't there be some basic grammar, associated with basic logical inferences and very abstract concepts such as object, property, agent, intention, motion, space and time...? I see no reason why such a basic framework couldn't be favoured by evolution. Of course we'd need more rules to account for the creation of new words (naming a particular object / property) and for abstraction (maybe a self-referential feature of the language) but it doesn't seem insurmountable.

    ReplyDelete
  2. In scripting/coding languages there are a number of switches/principles shared and used thoroughly as a means - perhaps this is significant in comparison to human language (If and Else statements. Yes and no. Or even an Exit status to kill the script).

    ReplyDelete
  3. Which Coding language are talking about?

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Nice to read your article! I am looking forward to sharing your adventures and experiences.
    Logo design service

    ReplyDelete
  6. Cosplay Beautiful Girl #1

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AUSupzySU-o

    Cosplay Beautiful Girl #2

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JX-go470MOk

    Cosplay Beautiful Girl #3

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LxOW0ALxVls

    Cosplay Beautiful Girl #4

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lyBvFtu2r2k

    Cosplay Beautiful Girl #5

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XSvBvJgOktY

    Cosplay Beautiful Girl #6

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rrkCUyRgQ2k

    The secret love of brother and sister

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u9QwZnUm00U

    Two cute sisters share boyfriend

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ylOMhGIo9xA

    Young girl with natural beauty

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=42k8mkRn36I

    Beautiful young teacher with sexy breasts

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IM1q_H_weew

    Young girl 's father attacked her husband

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5BJmUTJo1Qk

    Beautiful young girl with sexy body

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q5WLVcVZC0k

    Beautiful young stepmother with son's friend

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8vLnPl_6Z9k

    biet thu Brg Coastal City

    http://brgcoastalcitys.com/

    Bat Dong san nOi bat

    http://batdongsannoibat.com/

    ReplyDelete
  7. Masker yang Paling Tepat Digunakan di Kabut Asap
    ------------------------------------------------
    Bencana kabut asap belum juga berakhir. Terkait bencana tersebut, beberapa waktu lalu ada perbedaan pendapat mengenai jenis masker apa yang paling cocok digunakan warga yang terpapar asap.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thank you for posting such nice article read. I am very glad to read this. Really good one.
    Bangalore Web Designing Company, Web Development Company Bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  9. A very well-written post. I read and liked the post and have also bookmarked you. All the best for future endeavors. Getting some solution regarding.
    UI Design Companies in Bangalore, Web Application Development Companies in Bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  10. Nice! I never see "Innateness Hypothesis" but now I find it!

    ReplyDelete
  11. AquaQQ | Agen Poker Online | Bandarq Terpercaya | Agen Domino QQAgen Poker Terpercaya, Agen Domino Terpercaya, Bandar Ceme Online, Agen Capsa Susun, Agen Aduq Online, Bandarq Online

    Agen Poker Terpercaya
    Agen Domino Terpercaya
    Agen Capsa Online
    Domino99
    Agen DominoQQ
    Agen BandarQ
    Unyu Update

    ReplyDelete
  12. AquaQQ | Agen Poker Online | Bandarq Terpercaya | Agen Domino QQAgen Poker Terpercaya, Agen Domino Terpercaya, Bandar Ceme Online, Agen Capsa Susun, Agen Aduq Online, Bandarq Online

    Agen Poker Terpercaya
    Agen Domino Terpercaya
    Agen Capsa Online
    Domino99
    Agen DominoQQ
    Agen BandarQ
    Unyu Update
    Agen DominoQQ
    Agen DominoQQ

    ReplyDelete